Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Syracuse
Best Italian Restaurants in Syracuse

Best Italian Restaurants in Syracuse

Curated guide featuring 8 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars

Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Syracuse

Sicily's crown jewel of Syracuse isn't just about ancient Greek theaters and baroque architecture – it's a culinary paradise where authentic Italian flavors reach their most soulful expression. Here, family-run trattorias serve recipes passed down through generations alongside innovative spots that reimagine Sicilian classics, all while the Mediterranean breeze carries the scent of fresh seafood and simmering sauces through narrow cobblestone streets. The magic happens in intimate dining rooms where passionate chefs transform the island's incredible local ingredients into unforgettable meals that capture the very essence of southern Italian hospitality.

This guide showcases 10 exceptional Italian restaurants that have earned their stellar reputations one satisfied diner at a time, each boasting ratings of 4.5 stars or higher from thousands of genuine reviews. From hidden gems tucked away in Ortigia's winding alleys to beloved neighborhood spots where locals gather nightly, you'll discover where to find the city's most spectacular fried fish, handmade pasta that melts on your tongue, and those perfect wine-paired evenings that make Syracuse dining so special. These aren't just restaurants – they're the beating heart of Syracuse's incredible food culture.

Featured Restaurants

Cod da Saretta, Merluzzo fritto
$

Cod da Saretta, Merluzzo fritto

★★★★☆
4.8
(1,733 reviews)

This beloved Siracusa gem specializing in fried cod has won over nearly 1,800 diners with its authentic preparation and wallet-friendly prices, earning an impressive 4.8-star rating that speaks to consistently excellent food and service. The restaurant's focus on fresh, perfectly battered cod draws both locals and visitors who appreciate no-frills Italian seafood done right. Given its popularity and prime location near Via Maestranza, arrive early or be prepared to wait for a table at this crowd-pleasing spot.

Via maestranza 134, Via Nizza, 8, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
392 115 7454
MOON - Move Ortigia Out of Normality
$$

MOON - Move Ortigia Out of Normality

★★★★☆
4.8
(1,622 reviews)

This trendy bar in Syracuse's historic center lives up to its name by offering something refreshingly different from the typical tourist spots, creating an atmosphere that truly moves beyond the ordinary. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 1,600 reviews, travelers consistently rave about the creative drinks, welcoming vibe, and perfect location on Via Roma for exploring Ortigia. Arrive in the early evening to snag a good spot and experience the bar at its buzzing best before it gets packed with locals and fellow travelers.

Via Roma, 112, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
PastaRun
$

PastaRun

★★★★☆
4.9
(1,090 reviews)

This beloved local gem on Corso Umberto I has won over more than a thousand diners with its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere, earning an impressive 4.9-star rating that speaks to consistently excellent food and service. The restaurant's variety of cuisines and budget-friendly prices make it a perfect spot for travelers seeking authentic flavors without breaking the bank. Given its popularity and stellar reputation, consider making a reservation or arriving early to secure a table at this Syracuse favorite.

Corso Umberto I, 136, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
348 702 0756
Trattoria La Pigna
$$

Trattoria La Pigna

★★★★☆
4.8
(909 reviews)

Tucked away on Via della Conciliazione in Syracuse, Trattoria La Pigna has earned a devoted following with its authentic atmosphere and diverse menu that showcases the best of local flavors. With nearly 1,000 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.8-star rating, this charming spot consistently delivers exceptional food and warm hospitality that keeps both locals and travelers coming back. Book ahead during peak season, as this hidden gem's reputation for quality at reasonable prices makes it a highly sought-after dining destination.

Via della Conciliazione, 12, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
338 960 1407
Oz Ortigia
$$

Oz Ortigia

★★★★☆
4.8
(527 reviews)

This highly-rated bar in Ortigia's historic heart has earned a stellar reputation among locals and travelers alike, with nearly 530 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and quality offerings. The consistent 4.8-star rating speaks to exceptional service and a memorable experience that keeps guests returning. Arrive early in the evening to secure a good spot and soak up the authentic Sicilian bar culture in this charming corner of Syracuse's old town.

Via Santa Teresa, 9, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
Vibes - Ristorante Trattoria
$$

Vibes - Ristorante Trattoria

★★★★☆
4.6
(523 reviews)

This charming trattoria on Via dei Mille has won over hundreds of diners with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that showcases both local Sicilian specialties and international favorites. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 500 reviews, travelers consistently praise the friendly service and quality dishes that offer excellent value for money. Book ahead during peak season, as this popular spot fills up quickly with both locals and visitors seeking authentic Italian hospitality.

Via dei Mille, 7, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
327 472 7454
Anchovies Ortigia
$$

Anchovies Ortigia

★★★★☆
4.8
(440 reviews)

Tucked away on Via Capodieci in historic Ortigia, Anchovies delivers an exceptional dining experience that has earned rave reviews from nearly 450 satisfied guests. This beloved local gem offers diverse cuisine options in an intimate setting that perfectly captures the charm of Syracuse's ancient island quarter. With such consistently high ratings, book ahead or arrive early to secure a table at this popular neighborhood favorite.

Via Capodieci, 17, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy
Ranieri - Cucina Chiacchiere e Vino
$$

Ranieri - Cucina Chiacchiere e Vino

★★★★☆
4.9
(402 reviews)

Nestled in Siracusa's charming Piazza San Giuseppe, Ranieri delivers an authentic Italian dining experience where good food meets warm conversation and excellent wine, as its name playfully suggests. With an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 400 reviews, travelers consistently rave about the welcoming atmosphere and quality dishes that showcase the best of Sicilian hospitality. Book ahead for evening service, as this local favorite fills up quickly with both tourists and locals seeking genuine Italian flavors.

P.za S. Giuseppe, 8, 96100 Siracusa SR, Italy

Culinary Experiences in Syracuse

Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences